VIRGINIA — Essentia Health will pay over $10,000 to practitioners to settle unfair labor practice allegations related to a 2025 strike.
The Minnesota Nurses Association, which announced the settlement in a news release Tuesday, Nov. 17, alleges 10 advanced practice providers, or APPs, weren't able to sign up for open shifts after the strike in the same manner they were before. The union said that raised "serious concerns about retaliation against workers" for striking, which is a federally protected right.
APPs across the Northland went on strike for 13 days in July 2025. The APPs in the settlement worked in Virginia, Duluth and Superior, Wisconsin. MNA alleged Essentia was violating labor law for refusing to bargain on a first contract. The strike ended without a resolution.
APPs include nurse practitioners, physician assistants, certified nurse midwives and clinical nurse specialists.
In addition to compensating the impacted healthcare workers, Essentia must distribute an official National Labor Relations Board notice informing current and former APPs of their labor rights, like the right to organize, strike and take collective action to improve working conditions. The notice must be sent to the workers and prominently displayed in Essentia facilities for 60 days.
MNA stated Essentia continues to deny wrongdoing. The union pointed to a Nov. 2 memo Essentia sent to its employees, in which Vice President of Labor Relations John Haberman "characterized the settlement as a decision to avoid the time and expense of further litigation."
In a statement, Essentia said its "care teams and leaders acted with integrity throughout last year’s strike initiated by the Minnesota Nurses Association, and we’ve emphasized transparency with our colleagues since that strike. Our intent in communicating with members of our care team was a good-faith effort to keep them updated on the process."
The union said under the settlement, Essentia cannot attempt to minimize the official NLRB notice.
“Essentia’s response to serious allegations of retaliation is to tell its employees that it did nothing wrong,” stated Essentia nurse practitioner Caitlin Campbell in MNA's release. “Meanwhile, they have agreed to compensation and to notify workers of their federally protected rights. Essentia’s leadership should spend less time defending its reputation and more time making sure workers can exercise those rights without fear.”
Underlying dispute finally under federal review
More than two years after Essentia APPs voted to unionize, the NLRB is reviewing the underlying question of whether the APPs can be part of one bargaining unit.
Over 400 APPs in Essentia's East Market — which stretches from the Brainerd lakes area to Ashland, Wisconsin, north to International Falls and south to Pierz — organized in July 2024, motivated by a variety of issues, including staffing concerns and nondisclosure agreements.
The NLRB regional director approved the unit shortly before the vote to unionize in July 2024. Essentia requested a review of that decision two days after the vote.
The appeal was held up in part because the five-member Board was left without enough members to make decisions after President Donald Trump fired one of its Democratic members in January 2025, with the member challenging the firing in court. It took nearly a year for the Board to regain quorum and start making decisions again.
Before the strike last year, an MNA spokesperson said it is unusual for an employer to take a case as far as Essentia had and not to start negotiations while the appeal is ongoing.
In July 2026, the Board finally agreed to review the case.
Essentia said the regional director's decision ignored years of case law and the proposed unit is "uniquely problematic."
One of the organization's main concerns is the scope of the unit, which covers nine hospitals and over 50 clinics. But the NLRB agreed with the regional director's decision to include all East Market locations in the bargaining unit.
Still at issue is whether what is known as the Health Care Rule applies to a unit that includes both hospitals and clinics. The Health Care Rule defines what groups of employees can organize at acute-care hospitals.
Both sides argue that ruling against them would lead to fragmentation of bargaining units, which the Health Care Rule was designed to prevent.
Essentia said bypassing the rule by including clinics and using "cherry-picked" employee groups would lead to "exceptional fragmentation."
"There could be one unit of pharmacists, for example. And then another unit of social workers. Occupational therapists and physical therapists could organize their own unit. As could mental health therapists and dieticians," Essentia wrote in its brief for the NLRB. "Under this scenario, there could be dozens of bargaining units within any single acute-care hospital, simply because unions side-stepped the Rule by including a non-acute facility in their petition."
The union has said if the rule is applied, it would instead have to create at least eight new bargaining units. In its brief, it argued that the Health Care Rule was not written with modern, highly integrated healthcare systems in mind.
"Their [Essentia and the American Hospital Association] arguments ... ignore the significant factual complexities presented by employees who work across multiple facilities, and would leave many APPs without any realistic avenue to exercise their rights."
-
KAXE's weekly list of concerts near you features Charley Wagner, Clay Fulton, Corey Medina & Brothers, Caige Jambor, and The Brothers Burn Mountain.
-
Events this week include holiday events in Hibbing, Nisswa, Walker, Bemidji, Grand Rapids and Baxter.
-
The city of Grand Rapids will sell a $150,000 property originally bought for the proposed facility and is moving forward with a leasing option at 1200 S. Pokegama Ave.