VIRGINIA — The federal district court of Minnesota has dismissed a lawsuit by a former Rock Ridge School Board member against the district and the board chair for a second time.
The order filed Monday, March 16, said Pollyann Sorcan failed to state a First Amendment retaliation claim in her 2023 suit. She filed the action after board members censured and removed her from committee assignments, and she was excluded from attending committee meetings after her removal.
Sorcan argued the action was in retaliation to her engaging in protected speech.
In Monday’s order, Judge John R. Tunheim opined that removal from committees is among the most common forms of internal discipline used by political bodies. Tunheim wrote that Sorcan’s committee removals did not prevent her from performing her duties or deprive her of any privilege, since the committees are purely advisory.
As for barring her attendance from committee meetings, the court did agree this was an adverse action against Sorcan, as a member of the public looking to attend a public meeting. But according to the order, her complaint failed to show this move was retaliatory.
The lawsuit was already dismissed once, but last year, the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals sent the case back after determining the former board chair named in the suit did not enjoy individual legislative immunity.
The Rock Ridge School Board separately removed Sorcan from office in 2024, after she attempted to help others overturn Board decisions and violated data privacy rules.
She unsuccessfully ran to fill that seat again in the subsequent special election.
-
Larissa Donovan/KAXERelatives confirmed that 17-year-old Dylon Oothoudt of Walker was the male found dead Sept. 13, 2026, in a Cass Lake yard. An autopsy ruled the death a homicide by gunshot wound. -
Contributed/Brainerd Fire Department FacebookThe National Weather Service and public safety officials will be able to use data collected by the Climavision radar installed Sept. 15, 2026, to inform weather warnings. -
Plus: MN Court of Appeals to host oral arguments at Pequot Lakes High School. -
Emma Krab/KAXEAll county cameras have been removed as of Thursday, Sept. 10, 2026. Cameras under city jurisdiction may remain. -
Lorie Shaull/KAXEThe Minnesota Pollution Control Agency is surveying people's fish-eating habits to help limit contaminants in water bodies and make fish safer to eat. -
Emma Krab/KAXEThe tax used to fund civic center improvements will end Dec. 31, 2026. -
Plus: Zebra mussels found at two lakes on the Leech Lake Band of Ojibwe Reservation; Pollution Control Agency seeks participants for fish consumption survey.
-
Leech Lake Band of Ojibwe staff also found starry stonewort in Six Mile Lake, near the city of Cass Lake. -
Larissa Donovan/KAXEThe Bemidji Planning Board voted 6-1 to prohibit new developments of data centers greater than 10,000 square feet during its meeting Sept. 14, 2026. -
Plus: DNR cancels mineral lease for Twin Metals; and ICE's immigration crackdown last winter may have ripple effects for farm labor during harvest season.
