© 2025

For assistance accessing the Online Public File for KAXE or KBXE, please contact: Steve Neu, IT Engineer, at 800-662-5799.
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Phenology Report: Winter tree ID tips help you bark up the right tree

An oak leaf lies in freshly fallen snow near Marine on St. Croix on Oct. 31, 2023.
KAXE
/
Charlie Mitchell
An oak leaf lies in freshly fallen snow near Marine on St. Croix on Oct. 31, 2023.

John Latimer’s phenology reports explore northern Minnesota’s seasonal changes, blending humor and curiosity to connect listeners with nature’s rhythms. This is the week of Dec. 17, 2024.

After describing last week’s successful Christmas Bird Count, John shared his tips for identifying winter trees.

Though most deciduous trees have been bare-branched for over a month, a few still cling to their leaves, catching our attention. Among them are the red oaks and the ironwoods. Ironwoods (also called hop-hornbeams) are easy to spot thanks to their smaller stature, golden-tan leaves, and unique bark, which forms long, spiraling strips.

A side-by-side comparison of a red oak leaf and a white oak leaf demonstrates the rounded tips of white oaks and the pointy tips of red oaks. The top image, which shows a pointy-tipped leaf, has this text superimposed: "Red oaks: pointed leaf tips. MN species: Northern red oak, Northern pin oak." The lower image, which shows a leaf with rounded tips, has this text superimposed: "White oaks: Rounded leaf tips. MN species: Bur oak, white oak, swamp white oak."
KAXE
/
Graphic by Charlie Mitchell. Original photography by iNaturalist user Matthew Thompson.
A side-by-side comparison of a red oak leaf and a white oak leaf demonstrates the rounded tips of white oaks and the pointy tips of red oaks.

The red oaks, including northern red oaks and pin oaks, also retain their leaves through winter. You can distinguish a red oak from a white oak by the pointed tips of the leaves – white oak leaves have rounded tips (and tend to lose their leaves in winter).

Distinguishing between the two red oaks takes a closer look. Pin oaks have deeply cut leaves with large, dramatic sinuses (the gaps between the lobes), while northern red oak leaves are less deeply lobed. Keep in mind, though, that red oaks like to hybridize, so you might come across leaves that don’t quite fit neatly into either category – nature likes to keep us on our toes!

Even without leaves, some trees offer clues for identification. Basswoods and red elderberries make winter walks more colorful with their large, vibrantly colored buds. Basswoods flaunt bright red buds, while red elderberries—ironically named—show off striking purple ones.

If you’re strolling through the woods and manage to ID some of these winter trees, give yourself a high five for botanical brilliance!

Topics

A side-by-side comparison of the leaves of a northern pin oak and a northern red oak shows the deeply cut lobes of the northern pin oak contrasting with the less exaggerated lobes of the northern red oak. The top image shows a starved-looking oak leaf and superimposed text reading, "Northern pin oak: Deeply cut lobes, skeletal look". The bottom image shows another oak leaf and superimposed text reading "Northern red oak: less deeply cut lobes, more substantial". Both images show fallen leaves lying in snow.
KAXE
/
Graphic by Charlie Mitchell. Original photography by iNaturalist user Matthew Thompson (top) and Charlie Mitchell (bottom)
A side-by-side comparison of the leaves of a northern pin oak and a northern red oak shows the deeply cut lobes of the northern pin oak contrasting with the less exaggerated lobes of the northern red oak.

  • Introduction (0:00-0:24)
  • Snow, rain, and first sub-zero temps (0:24-2:37)
  • Christmas Bird Count (2:37-3:50)
  • Snowflies (3:50-5:32)
  • Spotted knapweed (5:32-6:52)
  • Red elderberry and basswood buds (6:52-7:49)
  • Identifying oak species (7:49-9:17)
  • Rock fern, also known as the common polypody (9:17-12:00)
  • Conclusion (12:00-13:11)

What have you seen out there? Let us know: email us at comments@kaxe.org or text us at 218-326-1234.

That does it for this week! For more phenology, <b>subscribe</b> to our Season Watch Newsletter or visit the Season Watch Facebook page.

Latest stories

Funding for this project was provided by the Minnesota Environment and Natural Resources Trust Fund as recommended by the Legislative-Citizen Commission on Minnesota Resources (LCCMR).

Stay Connected
Charlie Mitchell (she/they) joined KAXE in February of 2022. Charlie creates the Season Watch Newsletter, produces the Phenology Talkbacks show, coordinates the Phenology in the Classroom program, and writes nature-related stories for KAXE's website. Essentailly, Charlie is John Latimer's faithful sidekick and makes sure all of KAXE's nature/phenology programs find a second life online and in podcast form.<br/><br/><br/>With a background in ecology and evolutionary biology, Charlie enjoys learning a little bit about everything, whether it's plants, mushrooms, or the star-nosed mole. (Fun fact: Moles store fat in their tails, so they don't outgrow their tunnels every time conditions are good.)